Step 43: numbers from source
Orientation
The auditor (PR 15, audit/mo-audit-2026-09-19-repo.md) and the lead
(audit/fable-reading-2026-09-19-repo.md) both reproduced this on main: a
sized integer literal outside its type passes mo check and reaches both
runtimes, and an oversized mailbox: bound passes the checker and panics the
compiler. Mo’s own diagnostic says “overflow is never implicit”; today that is
false. Causes, lead-read: toolchain/src/check.zig checkLiteral (line 672)
copies at most 32 digits and drops the rest, and maps a parse overflow to
maxInt(u64), which then fits UInt64; parseInt in bytecode.zig:1709 and
emit_c.zig:1366 saturates an i128, so a 54-digit literal becomes a number
the source never held; mailbox is narrowed with @intCast
(bytecode.zig:1318, emit_c.zig:950) and never checked. Worker: a fresh
Claude Opus session, bypass permissions, own worktree and Herdr tab, based on
main at the PR 15 merge (launched before step 41 lands, because the defect is
in the language’s core claim; the lead accepts the merge work). Small and
sharp. No new syntax.
Write scope
toolchain/src/**, toolchain/bench/step37/fuzz.py and its tests, new corpus
or checker tests under examples/ with sidecars, and in
mo-wiki/spec/design-v0/ only the one line that states a mailbox bound’s
range if none exists (say which file in the report). No runtime C beyond what a
test needs, no harness, no other wiki, no audit/, HANDOFF.md. No machine,
no push. Never use tr; ls is aliased, use /bin/ls. Another worker (step
41, Exec) is editing toolchain/src (check.zig, types.zig, vm.zig,
caps.zig, prelude.zig) at the same time in its own worktree: keep the
diff small and local so the merge is easy.
Parts
- RED first, committed before any fix, as checker tests and as programs
run under
mo check,mo runand amo buildbinary. The probes are inaudit/evidence/2026-09-19/fable-repo-reading/and the PR’saudit/evidence/2026-09-19-repo/core/:UInt6418446744073709551616;UInt8with 32 leading zeros then 256;Int8with leading zeros then 200; a 54-digit literal; negative pattern literals at each signed minimum and one past it; every sized type at its maximum (accepted) and one past (refused); underscores anywhere legal;mailbox:4294967296 and a 26-digit bound. - One parser of numbers. A single function returns the exact value or
“too large”, with no digit buffer and no saturation; the checker, the
bytecode lowering and the C emitter all use it, and lowering may assume the
checker has passed.
MO0217for literals. The message prints the literal as written. - The mailbox bound. A source diagnostic, not a panic. Decide the range with a reason in the report: the lead’s default is 1 to 4,294,967,295, and 0 refused, unless the spec or a corpus program gives 0 a meaning (then say which). Reuse an existing code if one fits; a new code goes in the catalog.
- The sweep. Find every other place a number or size is read from source
text or narrowed from a wider integer in the compiler (durations and their
units,
within:, budgets, ports,restartlimits, repeat counts, float literals, escapes like\u{...}), with file and line, and for each: a test that the out-of-range form is a diagnostic. Any@intCaston a value that came from source is suspect. The table goes in the report. Also answer, with a test either way: can a minimumDurationorInt64be negated by any route the checker accepts (0 - x,abs,* -1), and what happens in each runtime. - The fuzz driver.
--minutesmust be finite and positive and--batchpositive, refused before setup with exit 2; a campaign that exercised zero inputs never exits 0. The mocked controls in the PR’sfuzz-controls.pyshow the present behaviour; add the driver’s own tests.
Done when
Every process under toolchain/bench/step36/guard.py; after any kill, check
for orphaned test binaries. zig build exit 0; focused tests by
-Dtest-filter with real summary lines and exit codes; the corpus still
formats and checks (mo fmt --check, mo check over examples/), since a
stricter checker may refuse a corpus program: report any, do not edit them to
pass without saying so. The unfiltered full suite and Linux are the lead’s.
Small commits as yourself with a Co-Authored-By line naming your model.
Write your final report to toolchain/STEP-43-REPORT.md and commit it.
While anything runs, wait in the foreground.
Result
Accepted 1:59 PM ET, 19 Sep 2026, merged to main through lead/verify-step43
(4ad89c1a). Worker: Claude Opus 5, report toolchain/STEP-43-REPORT.md.
Darwin full suite 263 of 263, exit 0, 11 minutes; Linux x86_64 build and 15 of
15 focused tests. Every probe of the auditor and the lead is now MO0217. The
sweep found three defects nobody had named (floats with stray underscores read
as 0, a float past Float64 read as infinity, max_restarts: 4294967295 read as
no budget). Left open, on the decision log: -128 as an Int8 expression
stays refused; per 0.ms has no stated meaning; a crash report’s source span
runs to the end of the line inside an interpolation. Evidence:
audit/evidence/2026-09-19/fable-lead-verification/step43/.