Step 27: what round 6 found
Robert’s three calls of 14 Sep afternoon, on control-run-6’s reading, and the small items its Mo worker recorded. Chapter 2’s “Session 6 changes” states the rules; this brief builds them.
Orientation
spec/design-v0/02-laws.md (the shape laws and the contract laws, and “Session 6 changes”), spec/grammar.md (the keyword list at line 17, old and result at 70 and 115), spec/design-v0/04-syntax.md (the struct-change idiom at line 147, the never sentence at 140), toolchain/src/lexer.zig, parser.zig (step 25’s field positions, step 26’s keyword sentence), check.zig (MO0302; how a run records values for T.all), vm.zig and runtime/mo_rt.c (where values are recorded), errors.zig, examples/rejects/ (the MO0302 file, state-binding.mo, var-state.mo, old-parameter.mo), ../mo-lang-control6-mo/examples/programs/logstat/TOOLCHAIN-BUGS.md and jobq/TOOLCHAIN-BUGS.md (the three reproductions, read only, that worktree is evidence).
Write scope
toolchain/, examples/, and these spec lines only: the keyword list and the old/result lines of grammar.md with a “Session 6, step 27” note; the string-literal production of grammar.md for the escape; 04-syntax.md’s line 147 sentence gains “and a never cannot see the copy between the assignments”; the fold_lines row of 09-stdlib.md and PRELUDE.md. Branch session-05, one commit per part, Step 27 part X in the subject, push after every commit, zig build test green at every commit.
Part A: the file law goes
MO0302 retired: the check removed, the catalog row marked retired as earlier retired rows are (or removed, whichever the catalog does), the rejects/ file for it removed, errors.md regenerated, zig build errors. The function, parameter, nesting, and state-field laws untouched, their rejects files still refused.
Part B: state, result, and old as names
The lexer keeps the three as keywords only where the grammar reserves them, or the parser accepts them as names in every other position; the worker chooses and says which in the report. Reserved: state opening a process’s state block and as the bare process state inside update, invariant, and a process’s own functions; old( inside ensures and invariant; result inside ensures. Everywhere else, a parameter, a binding, a var, a field, a for or comprehension name, a pattern binding, and a message or variant field take them. Step 26’s keyword sentence is kept only for the reserved positions (a bare state = 1 inside an update still says what it says). Corpus: types/keyword-fields.mo extended with state and result as parameters and bindings in a plain function and old as a for name; rejects/var-state.mo and rejects/old-parameter.mo become the reserved cases or go, rejects/state-binding.mo moves its binding inside an update; a rejects/ file for result outside ensures if it is still refused. jobq, agent, and any corpus file that renamed around these words may keep their names.
Part C: a never reads values at rest
The runtime (both) records a value for T.all when it rests: a binding, a field write’s whole struct once the statement ends and the next statement is not an assignment to the same var, a return, a message, an assertion; not the var between two field assignments of one body. The simplest rule the worker finds that makes the round 6 reproduction pass and keeps every never in the corpus tripping where it trips today, said in the report. Corpus: contracts/never-var-copy.mo with the round 6 Pair reproduction as a passing test plus a never that still trips when the pair is returned unequal; contracts/never-trips.mo still trips.
Part D: the small items
- A
\u{XXXX}escape in a string literal (1 to 6 hex digits, a Unicode scalar value), andMO0101at any other backslash escape the lexer does not know, saying which escapes exist.basics/strings.mogains one of each kind; arejects/file for"\q". resultas a name outsideensuresno longer needs a sentence after part B; if it stays refused anywhere, the sentence step 26 gavestateandold.Fs.fold_linesat a line that is not UTF-8: the plainest shape that lets a caller count the line and keep folding, chosen by the worker (aNotTextthat carries the fold so far and the line’s index, or the line handed to the function as bytes-replaced text with a flag), said in the report, with the09-stdlib.mdandPRELUDE.mdrows.
Part E: both runtimes and the corpus
Every changed corpus file under mo test, --sim 100, and as a --tests binary; mo fmt --check clean; the whole suite green.
Numbers
lex, parse, check bench rows before and after; the count of corpus files and of functions over 70 lines (expected 0); logstat-4k and kv-10k-get rows under both runtimes before and after part C, since recording changes.
Done when
Green at every commit; MO0302 gone; the three words as names with their corpus files; the never rule with its file and both runtimes; the escape, the diagnostic, and fold_lines; the numbers; pushed; a numbered list “Decisions the brief did not cover”.
Result
Accepted 14 Sep 2026, 16:50 UTC. Five commits in 48 minutes, green at each, 185 of 185. Part A: MO0302 and its plumbing gone, the other shape laws untouched. Part B: the lexer keeps the three tokens and the parser retags them as names outside the reserved positions; the keyword sentence stays for those positions and result gets its own; keyword-fields.mo extended, three rejects files moved to the reserved cases, rejects/unbound-result.mo new. Part C: a field write skips the T.all record when the next statement of the body assigns the same root name; both backends; contracts/never-var-copy.mo holds round 6’s Pair reproduction passing beside a half-moved copy that still trips. Part D: \u{X} in both backends, MO0101 at an unknown escape naming the escapes, fold_lines past a non-UTF-8 line with U+FFFD; basics/strings.mo, rejects/unknown-escape.mo, programs/not-text.mo updated. Part E: bench rows. Numbers (best of 20): lex 7,091 → 6,816 µs, parse 17,524 → 17,038, check 61,367 → 59,202 over 151 → 154 files; logstat-4k 103.9 → 105.5 ms interpreted, 13.7 → 13.9 native; kv-10k-get within noise; no function over 70 lines (longest 48).
Fable’s probes: a 606-line file accepted; state and result as parameters and bindings and old as an anonymous function’s parameter in a plain function, under mo test and as a test binary; state as a process parameter refused with the sentence; the Pair reproduction passing and the half-moved copy tripping in both runtimes; "\u{85}" two bytes, "\u{1F600}" four, "\q" refused; fold_lines counting one non-UTF-8 line of three from mo run and the binary. Found on the side: a wrong duration unit (1.second) crashes at run time with “second is a field of a type tier 2 cannot see” instead of a check-time diagnostic naming the units; to housekeeping.