Comparison pass: brief for the worker session
Thirteen pages in research/comparisons/, one per shortlist entry in language-landscape. Written by a worker session (Opus) with fresh web research; reviewed by Claude (Fable) and Robert. This page is the full brief. Robert’s rule: nothing here is decided until he says so — these pages inform the v0 design doc, they don’t change directions on their own.
Orientation (do first, every session)
- Read
HANDOFF.md,SCHEMA.md,index.md, the tail oflog.md. - Read
research/concepts/language-landscape.md(the shortlist and why each entry is there) anddeep-dives/steal-list.md(what session 1 already took). - Skim
directions/titles (30) andquestions/titles (17) so you know which Mo decision each language touches.index.mdhas one line per page.
Tools
- Web research:
source ~/.zshenv && python3 tools/exa.py search "..." -n 10/contents URL/answer "..."/research "task". Also plain WebFetch/WebSearch. Prefer primary sources: language site, spec, repo, papers. - Papers: arXiv API (
https://export.arxiv.org/api/query?search_query=...) — wait ≥3s between calls, it rate-limits hard. Semantic Scholarhttps://api.semanticscholar.org/graph/v1/paper/search?query=.... - Citations:
python3 .claude/skills/grounded-citations/scripts/sources.py --ledger research/comparisons/.ledger.json add URL --title "..."returns[n]; cite inline as[n]; finish withrender --cited-in PAGE >> PAGEandverify PAGE. One shared ledger for the whole pass; never renumber. - Raw sources: save any page or paper you lean on to
raw/articles/<slug>.mdorraw/papers/<slug>.mdwith frontmattersource_url,ingested: YYYY-MM-DD,sha256of the body.raw/is immutable once written. - Lint:
python3 tools/lint.pymust be clean before every commit. - Commit after each finished page:
git add -A && git commit -m "Comparison: <Language>" && git push. Commit trailers per the session’s system reminder.
Page template (research/comparisons/<slug>.md)
---
title: "Mo vs <Language>"
created: 2026-09-12
updated: 2026-09-12
type: comparison
tags: [research, <one or two from the taxonomy>]
sources: [raw/articles/<slug>.md, ...]
confidence: medium
---
# Mo vs <Language>
**One line:** what this language is and why it's on the list.
## What it is (status as of Sep 2026)
Release stage, activity, who's behind it, domain. 3–6 sentences, cited.
## The ideas, one by one
For each distinctive idea (3–7 of them):
- **Idea** — what it does, in two sentences with a ≤8-line code snippet if syntax matters.
- *Mo today:* which direction / question / syntax pick already covers this (link it: `[[d15-effects-via-capabilities|direction 15]]`).
- *Verdict:* **steal** / **already have** / **reject** / **open** — and one sentence why.
## What it gives up
The costs the language accepts, and whether Mo accepts the same ones.
## Evidence
Anything measured: performance numbers, adoption, study results, LLM benchmarks. Cited. "No evidence found" is a valid line.
## What Mo should take from this
Bullet list, each item a concrete proposal or a question for Robert. Mark anything that would **contradict an existing direction** with ⚠️ and name the direction — do not resolve it, surface it.
## Related
- [[language-landscape]]
- links to the directions/questions/picks this page touched (≥2)
## Sources
(rendered by sources.py)Keep pages under ~180 lines. Snippets under 10 lines. Three-column tables max. Phone-readable.
The thirteen, with what to look for
- elixir — Elixir v1.20’s gradual set-theoretic types (inference-first, no annotations, “verified bugs”); OTP supervision shapes vs Mo’s declared
supervisor(Q7); what Elixir 1.20+ shows about typed BEAM ergonomics. Touches d7, d14, d18, q7. - go — what Go’s “simplicity by law” is precisely (gofmt, no generics for a decade, stdlib policy, module proxy + checksum DB for Q17);
if err != nilvs Mo’stry; goroutines vs Mo processes. Touches d12, d23, q11, q17. - rust — traits, enums, exhaustiveness,
Result/Option, the borrow checker’s cost to humans and agents (find studies), compile-time causes; what Mo keeps (d22) and drops. Touches d22, d23, q5, p15. - roc — platforms in detail (how a platform is written, the app/platform boundary, the effect interpreter), Perceus-style memory, the Zig rewrite numbers, Roc’s abilities vs Mo traits. Touches q11, d24, d25, q13.
- koka — effect types + handlers vs Mo’s capability parameters (d15); Perceus with reuse (the memory model Mo wants); compile-to-C. Touches d15, d16, d10, d24.
- austral — linear types, capability-based security, the “no magic” spec; how capabilities are obtained at the root and threaded; what linearity would buy Mo for resources/deadlines. Touches d15, p13, q16, q17.
- hylo — mutable value semantics precisely (projections,
inout,set,sink), how it avoids aliasing, generics; new compiler status. Touches d13, d10, p3. - unison — content-addressed definitions, codebase-as-database, exact dependencies by hash, hash-cached tests, why text files were dropped and what that cost adoption. Touches q10, d29, d23, q17.
- moonbit — the shipping “AI-native toolchain”: what MoonBit Pilot does, the ICSE 2024 semantics-aware sampling paper, multi-backend, what its language actually looks like, adoption. The closest competitor; be specific. Touches d1, q9, q10, q13.
- bosque — regularized programming (no loops, no mutable state, no reference equality), Mark Marron’s papers, why the project stalled (find the history), what Bosque 2.0 / recent commits look like. Touches d4, d10, q12, p11.
- spark-ada-and-dafny — contracts as language with prover + runtime semantics (SPARK); Dafny’s 82% LLM proof rate (vericoding benchmark 2509.22908), Dafny-as-IL (2501.06283), Marmaragan (2502.07728); what contract shapes LLMs discharge well. Touches d3, d22, q8, p8.
- agent-native-cluster — one page for Intent, Vera, Thermite, Vow, Aver, AILANG, Hale, Tacit, Zero, Codong, Axis, plus Neam and NTNT (not in the catalogue; verify they exist). For each: two lines + what overlaps Mo. Then: what did 42 fresh attempts converge on? Touches d1, d3, q9, q10, q12.
- verse — functional logic + transactional semantics (every function inside a transaction that can roll back), structured concurrency, Simon Peyton Jones’s papers; could transactions replace or complement crash-and-restart (d18, d21)? Wildcard; be skeptical. Touches d18, d21, d14.
Order
Do them in the order above (1 → 13). One page at a time, commit after each. If a page needs more than ~90 minutes, write what you have, mark confidence: low, and move on.
When done
- Append to
log.md: one entry per page (## [date] ingest | Comparison: <Language>). - Add each page to
index.mdunder Research. - Write
research/concepts/comparison-synthesis-draft.md: the ⚠️ contradictions across all 13, the top ten steals, and open questions for Robert — a draft for Fable to finish, not a decision. - Update
HANDOFF.md“Where we stopped”.
Progress
Finished pages, in order (worker session):
- Elixir
- Go
- Rust
- Roc
- Koka
- Austral
- Hylo
- Unison
- MoonBit
- Bosque
- SPARK Ada + Dafny
- Agent-native cluster
- Verse
Synthesis draft for Fable: comparison-synthesis-draft